Observational studies take on various forms. There are various types of observational research, each of which has strengths and weaknesses. These types are organized below by the extent to which an experimenter intrudes upon or controls the environment.
Naturalistic observation
Naturalistic observation refers to a method where researchers study participants in their natural environment without manipulating variables or intervening in any way. It provides a realistic snapshot of behavior as it occurs in real-life settings, thereby enhancing ecological validity.
Examples of naturalistic observation include people-watching in public places, observing animal behaviors in the wild, and longitudinally studying children's social development at school. This method can reveal insights about behavior and relationships that might not surface in experimental designs, such as patterns of social interaction, routines, or responses to environmental changes.
Participant observation
Participant observation is similar to naturalistic observation, except that the researcher is part of the natural environment they are observing. In such studies, the researcher is also interested in rituals or cultural practices where they can only determine their value by actually experiencing them firsthand. For example, any individual can understand the basic rules of baseball by watching a game or following a team. Participant observation, on the other hand, allows for direct participation to develop a better sense of team dynamics and relationships among fellow players.
Most commonly, this process involves the researcher inserting themselves into a group to observe behavior that otherwise would not be accessible by observing from afar. Participant observation can capture rich data from the interactions with those who are observed to the reflections of the researchers themselves.
Controlled observation
A more structured observation involves capturing the behaviors of research participants in an isolated environment. Case-control studies have a greater resemblance to experimental research while still relying on observational research methods. Researchers may utilize a case-control study when they want to establish the causation of a particular phenomenon.
For example, a researcher may want to establish a structured observation of a control group and an experimental group, each with randomly assigned research participants, to observe the effects of variables such as distractions on people completing a particular task. By subjecting the experimental group to distractions such as noise and lights, researchers can observe the time it takes participants to complete a task and determine causation accordingly.